Re-gifting

Helenahhandbasket

This is somewhat inspired by the "SIL is a Peach" thread.

What do we all think about re-gifting for a baby shower?  Obviously I am talking about brand new, unused baby gifts that would be useful and make sense to give?

I personally think it's OK-- IF the gift makes sense.  Like, I wouldn't re-gift a brand new nursing cover to a MTB that I knew was FFing (using this example because I do have an unused nursing cover) or a size 3 month snowsuit to a baby born in June (also have that!).

I have a bunch of really nice gifts that I have never opened and wondered what others think about this.

What say you BSB?