Car window shades

ArcticFox

I've been through so many of these in the past 4+ years!!

The suction cup ones never seem to stay on.

The ones that clip on the top of the window - every time I open the window, they come off (stick in the top of the window frame), and then there's a big crunch when I try to close the window.  I try to never open the back windows any more but sometimes DH or I forget.

Does anyone have a window shade they love?  Are there cling ones that work well?

I also find that when the shade is down, they never stay stuck to the window (suction cup at the bottom) and then the kids play with them, so then they don't work well (suction cup gets worse and the shade doesn't shade well).