Big girl bedding - need opinions

raceyrae

We've decided to move Claire to her big girl bed soon.  Eventually, she'll be moved into Natalie's room to share the room so I planned to get her matching bedding like Natalie has.  Well, turns out the set Natalie had is no longer available so I'm looking to get two sets of bedding now so when they're sharing a room, it coordinates.  These are the two I'm thinking of.  Which do you like better?

The walls are lavender and they have some polka dot things already (PBK chairs that are green with white polka dots and the cover to their toychest has green with different colored polka dots) so I thought I need to keep that in the theme somehow.

This one with purple polka dot sheets for one and green polka dots for the other,

Or this one -- purple polka dot duvet for one and green dots for the other.

I really like the quilt one (first one) but wasn't sure if the polka dots and different squares on the quilt was too much.

TIA