I'm glad now that I've ended up sharing name ideas with you guys - at least I have someone to get opinions from since this is turning out to be so difficult for us. We've pretty much decided that Savannah will be the middle name now, which is totally fine. I'm so happy that we'll get to use it to honor my grandpa. But we still cannot agree on a first name! Here are our new options - I'd love your input. And just a reminder - please keep it quiet on FB.
Riley
Zoe
Carley/Carly
Allison (this name I'm not thrilled with, but I do love the nn Allie)