Would this be silly (would you do this?)

MelissaSue81

So Eve has a really nice area rug in her room.. its from rhbabyandchild.com

http://www.rhbabyandchild.com/catalog/product/product.jsp?productId=rhbc_prod139001&categoryId=rhbc_cat199011

We paid full price for it (Which I actually thought was more than $150..but whatever).. 

Its now on sale for $75.. Would you get the same rug (with and N instead of an E) for Natalies room? Or would that be silly? I fully intend on Eve keeping the rug she has, i'm picking her bedding to match it specifically because i love it and its expensive!